SECRET INVASION #8 (OF 8)

Review by: daccampo

What did the
iFanboy
community think?

807
Pulls
Avg Rating: 3.3
 
Users who pulled this comic:


Size: pages
Price: 3.99

This review contains spoilers, click here to read

Story: 3 - Good
Art: 3 - Good

Comments

  1. Good review this.

  2. coltrane68 coltrane68 says:

    Good review, but….

     

    It ignores the fact that this wasn’t a story in itself – rather, it’s just a set up for another crossover story. Is Bendis an architect or a writer?

  3. Paul Montgomery PaulMontgomery (@fuzzytypewriter) says:

    Great, balanced review, Dave.  With excellent references to an excellent outside source.  ;)

    I stopped reading Si after the third or 4th issue and decided to wait for the trade.  I agree that the serialization hurt this one, and I really look forward to reading it in one big chunk.   

  4. daccampo daccampo says:

    @coltrane — I disagree with the notion that it wasn’t a story in itself. It clearly was. I wrote: "The Skrulls lost their world, they believe Earth is theirs by divine right. They set up a clever strategy and made their best go of it. But they couldn’t beat the combine might of Earth’s heroes and villains." That’s the story. It has a beginning, middle, and an end. Whether you thought it was a GOOD story is something we can debate endlessly. ;)

     

  5. VogonPoet30 VogonPoet30 says:

    About half of this series was made up of mindless, traditional battles, and the climactic end fight scene took up all of issue seven, so it’s not like he’s skipping over it.  That being the case, though, you’re right that the more important moments within the big battles were kind of rushed over or incomprehensible (see: Giant Purple Death-Janet).

  6. daccampo daccampo says:

    I disagree. The earlier skirmishes were very quick but not pointless. They would, say, show the Skrulls landing in NYC and the young Avengers fighting. But they were glossed over quickly and cut away from. Bendis isn’t interested in those things. He’d drop into smaller moments, moments of distrust. He’s much more comfortable having Cage and Logan argue with each other for several pages. 

    Also: that was my point about giant janet — he shows it, but doesn’t focus on it. It’s presented after-the-fact. She doesn’t really get a death scene. She’s just decoration in the background. 

     

  7. VogonPoet30 VogonPoet30 says:

    And I agreed with that point…

  8. Kimbo Kimbo says:

    great review, I couldn’t agree more with your points.  This is one event book that definitely felt like it had a conclusion while leaving strings to follow into the next storyline.  And it’s all taking place in an afternoon, a day at best.

Leave a Comment