POWER GIRL #12

Review by: PraxJarvin

What did the
iFanboy
community think?

360
Pulls
Avg Rating: 4.6
 
Users who pulled this comic:
Users who reviewed this comic:
Written by JIMMY PALMIOTTI and JUSTIN GRAY
Art and cover by AMANDA CONNER

Size: 32 pages
Price: 2.99

Twelve months ago, I was so enamored with the first issue of a title that I was motivated to write a review for it. That book was Power Girl #1 by Jimmy Palmiotti, Justin Gray and Amanda Conner with Paul Mounts and John J. Hill. Power Girl was a breath of fresh air in my pull list at the time. It wasn’t an event tie-in, it wasn’t laden in continuity, it wasn’t overly dark and – most of all – it was fun. This is something we take for granted in recent comics. We’re so concerned with being “serious” stories with dire consequences for the whole publishing line that we’ve so often forgotten about our Superheroes being… well, Super!

Power Girl’s 12 issues were a delightful romp in the life of a DC heroine that many had written off based on her (admittedly) sexist appearance. But a few pages into the first issue and it became clear that the boobs were not an issue any longer. Power Girl was a fully developed woman behind the revealing costume with interesting relationships, enemies and experiences.

The reason I bring up my impressions of the first issue relates to the style of this issue. Palmiotti and Gray have decided to take the reader on a tour of the past 11 issues in order to tie-up loose ends before they exit the title. As a capper to their run on the book, it works really well. The feel of the book is never forsaken to squeeze in a joke to something that came before and the wrap-up does the best thing it could, leave you wanting more from this creative team. This issue touches on many of the best moments from the previous stories, but does the most for the Power Girl/Terra friendship, which has evolved naturally over the past year. The comedic moments surrounding PeeGee meeting Terra’s family were pure gold.

And of course, where would this book be without Amanda Conner? By far her art was the star of this book. Amazing work that could go toe-to-toe with some of the best “photo-realistic artists” in the biz. The subtle comedy of her work has crafted the charm of the book from subtle things like the organic way her PeeGee’s bangs move to the multi-panel scene with “Stinky” to the body language between Karen and Vartox. Amazing work.

At this point there isn’t much to say to get someone on to this book. It’s been a fantastic ride. And I heartily suggest picking this book up in trades if you’ve been reluctant to do so. A great fun read that will make you smile. I will most likely check out the Winnick issues – may hopes remain high for that – but I’ll always fondly remember the Conner, Palmiotti and Gray era on this book.

Story: 5 - Excellent
Art: 5 - Excellent

Comments

  1. Look at you with a review! 🙂

    Well said though, I really cannot wait for volume 2 of this to come out in trade. The first was good, although a bit wordy, but these last six issues seem to really struck a chord with comic readers. Wouldn’t be surprised about feeling the same way once I can finally read this. 

  2. I wanted something a little more heroic out of the new Power Girl series. Though I loved the art, I feel the team did not deliver.  

  3. This was a "must read" for me. I agree with every word of the review. The book was fun, and made me feel good after I read it. The cheesecake wasn’t over done… in fact, it made sense, especially with the light hearted tone in which the book was written. Conner’s artwork… what can I say? The facial expressions and body language were spot on. I’m really going to miss this team a lot. If PG survives the transfer, maybe someday we’ll see this star team return. I’ll keep my fingers crossed.

  4. i am so glad that Jimmy Palmoti and Amanda Conner are ending their run on Power Girl. She has been one of my favorite characters since her beginings and their treatment of her was atrocius. They made her a joke. The cartoonish artwork style of Amanda Conner was more than I could bear to look at. She looked like Archie Comics Betty on Steroids, and her gal pal Terra was no Better, it was Betty and Veronica in costumes. they went the humor route with PG, just sexist jokes, lame villians, bimbos from outer space. Amanda as an artist should never draw fior the super hero genre and her cartoonish quality art style,combined with Palmoti’s story telling just refused to let readers take her seriously. She was being handled well in every other book except her own. It was a shame and glad to see it end.

  5. Damn, that is the other perspective on this comic.

    I don’t agree, but I’m not sure I could argue against that . . . well, I could . . .

  6. That’s a lot of wrong packed into a little post.

Leave a Comment