SIEGE #1 (OF 4)
Review by: RKB
What did the
iFanboy
community think?
917
Pulls
Pulls
Avg Rating: 3.8
%7B%22comicdate%22%3A%222010-01-06%22%2C%22comicid%22%3A64986%7D
Users who pulled this comic:
- 0and18
- 23skidoo
- 70namrepuS
- 158hoff
- 182mark
- ABirdseysView
- aboris26
- AbrahamSamable
- ac507
- acamilo
- acbg
- Achaniel
- ActualButt
- adrian
- adrianhosseini
- adultbraces
- AdverseE
- Agent005
- ajmortys
- Ajs3000
- akamuu
- AL13N4112
- AlanMac
- AlanRob
- AleSanch
- alexb
- Alexferrer
- AlexG
- Ameer
- AmirCat
- amlah6
- ammcquillen
- Andrew
- Angelus
- AngryDad
- Animalvader1
- anrcampbell
- Anson17
- ApesRus
- APG
- apoptosis81
- Apotheosize
- Aqualeo
- AquaPimp82
- AquariusDog31
- arestocomics
- arquilla88
- Arrrggghhh
- asholds
- asigchris
- Askanison
- astoriajohnstons
- astyak
- atm
- atma
- ato220
- AtomEve
- austinite74
- Avenger117
- Avengersfan
- B
- babaoriley
- bakakaba
- Bakhox
- Baltika37
- bansidhewail
- BarbarianKing
- Barnabas
- Bassoonjedi
- batmanslayer
- battlecreek
- bazhorne
- BC1
- bcmiller189
- Ben
- benisjamino
- besighyawn
- BetaRayRyan
- betrayl
- bffnut
- Bibble
- biftec
- BigNathanB
- bigsime22
- bigyanks
- bilko1024
- bird
- BizDaddy
- bizreal1015
- bjohnsonmc
- blackspidey1963
- BladesofJustice
- blaque
- bluedream
- bnicholas1
- BobDigi76
- Bobtrombones
- BoldCoffee
- boostergold4
- Bootmobile
- box19
- braincloud
- brainhound
- Brian
- brianCarbordo
- brianmaru
- BrianPereira
- broderboy
- Brotodeau
- BruceLuvsClark
- bryanpittard
- Bryce31
- buckeyerdld
- Burgertime
- burn
- busboy
- ButchCassidy
- bzzzash
- cabernetfranc
- cactus4million
- CAM
- campbell
- canucklehead
- Canyonwalker
- capekweer
- capnho
- CaptainSweatpants
- captamerica101
- captbastrd
- CaptDS9E
- Cartographer
- CaseyJustice
- cav
- cecena1
- cenquist
- CGHER
- CGPO
- chad
- chadbowen248
- Chadonis
- chaosmonkey
- Chardsoul
- charlesp1138
- charliebf5
- chauncy23
- chewie810
- chiefjoe
- chris
- ChrisB
- chrisequalsgreat
- christopheduran
- chrs7637
- Chuckenigma
- Chunkahash
- citizenmilton
- clay
- ClaytonMoore
- CleophusWayne
- CleverJohnny
- clintaa
- CloudControl
- cmwnyc
- codymander
- ColdWarKid
- coleman
- Colinski
- coltrane68
- comicBOOKchris
- ComicBookGuy37
- ComicCrazyReviews
- comixfan
- conor
- conor9935
- Constable
- convoy83
- Cooper
- cormano
- cornflakes
- corpseed
- cosmicray
- CountAbyss
- counterproduct
- COWoDOOM
- cprevite
- Craigerymontoya
- Cranpa
- CrimsonDynamo
- Crin
- crippjsandman
- Crippler
- cromulent
- CronyC
- Cropcirkill
- crosseyedgreg
- Croz
- ctrosejr
- cubman987
- cutty
- Cyriso
- D
- daccampo
- Daflash00
- Dan
- danderson
- dandoody
- DanLikesBeer
- dannyrand
- danyst
- dapperdan
- darkmage
- Darksud
- darrenjackson
- darrinbru
- DarrinH
- DarthDuck
- dave
- davek
- daveofthedead
- davidd
- DavidMacfarlane
- davidtobin100
- Dcp
- dcrob
- DDevil1964
- DeadBear
- deadsmiley519
- dedzed
- deezer
- DefConPrime
- defjuan
- Demo916
- Demos
- Devastron
- devildog
- dexterslu
- dharmabum
- Diabhol
- djd
- djgarciarx
- DocHess
- DocSamson
- doctorsporen
- doomwad
- dopehat88
- DorianP
- Doski
- downisthenewup
- DrColossus
- drdeeeznutz
- dredscott33
- droll
- droptop80
- droracle
- Drummer
- dsfiligoi
- dshramek
- DTBrown72
- dubvader
- Dude
- DunDun
- dunefish
- dustin
- Earwigg
- EbonPinion
- edward
- eganmcconvey
- EgonSpengler
- Eitanman
- EJ
- ejz206
- ElvisPresto
- emberwistle
- emergencyexit
- emissary
- Ender35k
- ender1979
- English
- Eric
- EricDee598
- erikduane
- est1864
- esuarez27
- Euhin
- eureka375
- Evin
- Fanteisimo
- feiry
- FelixAdler
- Ferrian
- Fett02
- finestjuan
- Finn007
- firebird
- flaco
- flakbait
- flashfloyd35
- fleaman
- Flounder
- flounder56
- FluffNFluff
- ford
- formerboygenius
- FreeBozo
- frijolie
- frodog28
- fuso
- Fvckstick
- Gabe
- gaffergamgee
- gandalf25
- Garrett
- gat0rl1vebeatz
- Gaumer
- genaverse
- genelaw9
- GENX
- georgeXjr
- getupreggie22
- GForce
- ghettojourno
- GhostGrifter
- Gilgamesh417
- Gimpace
- girvan
- GKFinns
- GleepGlop
- GLNancy
- glunders
- glwarm76
- Goaler31
- goat77
- gobo
- gollygosh03
- Gotee12
- gothamcentral79
- grandemts
- Grayghost
- gree0245
- greenbillblue
- greendart32
- grendel77
- Grendel1972
- GrendelRK
- grigs
- GrimJack
- grottesco
- gservo
- Guardedmarman
- GungaDin
- Guthriefan
- GutterIsATool
- Habakkuk
- hakaider
- HammHamm81
- HankMcCoy
- Harske
- Hawkboy
- HaZaa
- Hazer75
- HBD
- HecticPlanet
- hellblazer101
- hellboy42
- hellzaphat
- HermitHomeboy
- HerrStarr
- HeX
- Hexsas
- hidefjohn
- hiragikawaii
- hoaznod
- Homer
- Hoshigaki
- Hulkamaniac
- iamskeptopotamus
- Ian
- IanF
- IanX
- ichthyophobic
- iDan
- iGotKittyPryde
- IMBGY11
- immortal
- InfectiousFunk
- insaneshow
- introvertedone
- IPunchFace
- irock316
- IroncladMerc
- iSteve
- ivithebatmanivi
- izzy88
- J4K3
- jabroniunc
- JackAcid
- JackBurton34
- jacketFace
- JacksonAlexandr
- jag2004
- james
- JAMESDEAN2020
- jamesschneider
- JamesSeals
- jamiefs
- jannaeh
- JaqueNargg
- Jaredan
- Jarrett
- jashcraft1014
- Jasonmatthew
- JBaughb
- Jediaxle
- Jedimasterrob2001
- JediShaft
- Jeffc
- jelontok
- JesseG
- JesTr
- JesusChrysler
- JesusSlanda
- JFernandes
- jfontana
- jforan21
- Jhewlett
- Jim
- JimBilly4
- JimmyD
- jimmyg
- Jimski
- jing7wei
- Jinnpo
- jisrael
- jjkish7
- JKExar
- jla728
- JLAvenger
- jlddlj11
- jmack
- JMF
- joawmeens
- JoeBanner
- JoeFX
- joenyc
- joeycardgame
- Johan
- John42
- JohnathanKong
- JohnnyStooge
- johnthrax
- JonBoy
- jonclifton
- jonloveless
- jono87
- Joppe
- jordanlyall
- josh
- Joshrector
- Journal
- jpizzy87
- JR
- jramsey1
- JRoUKno
- JRScherer
- jsbx
- jspegele
- jtrigg13
- juand182
- jubal1
- Jurassicalien
- jwimmer
- jwlanglois
- k5blazer
- kaonohi
- karatechop16
- katang
- Katharsis
- kaufman1972
- Kaylon
- kcekada
- kellansmith
- Kerrizor
- KevinAB
- kevinscomics
- kevsname72
- KickAss
- KidJayson
- KieronGillen
- killboi
- kingpinII
- kingpotato
- kndoubleu
- KnightFlight
- Kodaiji
- Kory
- krad00
- krwren
- krypto
- kryptogrowl
- kubrick1978
- kwisdumb
- kymsoke
- LadyTartan
- lantern4life
- Lantern1025
- LastDays
- Lawless
- Lelandp13
- leonard
- Leprechaun
- LeviHunt15
- Lewis
- lilmikeegee
- lincolnputnam
- liquidfiction
- LiquidSnake
- locustzzy
- LorryDrivingeek
- Lucien21
- LukeB
- Luthor
- lxbatista
- macdad34
- madderhorn
- MagnetGirl
- magnum240
- malakilii
- malpractice
- Mangaman
- mansuper
- Marbles
- MarcSpector
- marcushill73
- markfg
- marshak75
- martianmonkey
- marvelzombie
- MasterXell
- mattfox7669
- matthaber
- mattstev2000
- mc9457
- mcbaker
- medz
- MEGAHERO
- Michael1025
- michaelscott75
- Midness
- midwinter
- mikeandzod21
- MikeDee
- mikegraham6
- MikeHaseloff
- MikeOdd
- MikePositive
- mikeromo
- MikeSaxon
- milez42
- Minion
- misacke
- Misfit529
- MisterJ
- mitchster
- miyamotofreak
- mlilien
- modbbt
- mongo
- MoniBolis
- monkeeeboy
- Mookiblaylock
- Mooseman
- moron
- mosszilla
- MrBeebs37
- MrDVD14
- MrGlass
- mrlogical
- mrmccoy81
- mrmister
- mrowland90
- MrPhases
- Mrusfl
- MrWilson
- MrWrong
- msg3K
- muddi900
- mulletpeep
- musicologist86
- Mustbedamned
- Mykey
- mynameis
- Myrlyn314
- Nate
- NathanNicdao
- NawfalQ
- NealAppeal
- Neb
- neerdowell
- neftones
- NeoApocalypse
- nerdtastic1227
- neutralfeatures
- newtype1089
- nickfk25
- NJBaritone
- nmoline
- Nonraw
- Notahiro
- Noto
- Notsoevilsteve
- nroa
- ntn1015
- Ntpmcrtp
- nuclearman
- nyrock
- o1saq
- OccultPanda
- ocdavenger
- odare77
- odino1
- ohcaroline
- okc
- oldmanlogan88
- Omegadark
- OmegaFlight
- OnASunday
- Ongakuhenjin
- Onic
- OniDante
- Orange
- Oranparker
- Orykayd
- Osyris
- OwlyFan
- paeryn
- Parker
- patio
- paulieP
- PaulMontgomery
- petefic
- Peterparker18102
- peterporker
- peterpter
- petropeterson
- phess1
- phillyelmo
- phizeta564
- PiePod
- piscespaul
- playtape
- Pompster
- Poopmonster
- PostMan87
- PraxJarvin
- ProjectX2
- PTAhole
- Pumatastic
- punisher36
- pup
- purplex
- PV
- PymSlap
- QuayLewd
- queenrikki
- Quentin
- Quinn
- RaceMcCloud
- RadConsv
- Radmobile
- RahUniQue
- ramonschenk
- Ramulux
- RandoCalrissian
- Ratenef
- rayclark
- redcracker
- reg5000
- Reverend13
- reversematt
- RevJred
- RevolutionarySounds
- rhcoop24
- rian
- richardelgie
- RickyStardust
- rift1128
- RipperSix
- rivendell3
- rjl
- rjw3
- RKB
- RLPrime
- RMC
- roadcrew1
- robbiethegeek
- robbydzwonar
- Robotpaul
- robsavino
- rochvail
- RocketRacoon
- rockgod27
- rockingeek
- roejamsey
- Rofo
- RoiVampire
- ron
- Rooney
- rrrafa
- rubra
- rudeboy134
- Ruo21
- Rustyautoparts
- rwpos
- ryn2o01
- ryry
- ryu156
- s73v3r
- Sai
- SalPane
- SamIAm
- SamMorgan
- Sammy
- Sasquattch
- saturnmda
- Sauceda
- saweez
- SBomb232
- scallionsncreme
- SCOOTMAN
- ScorpionMasada
- ScottB
- ScottH
- ScottR33
- Scout
- Scratch113
- Scrawl
- Seba
- selftitled
- seNoj1
- Serdan66
- sethkushner
- shaunbat
- shenanigans
- ShonenRafa77
- SilentRob
- SilverAgeTom
- Simon
- siraim
- SirCox
- Sirhc6934
- SirSullymore
- sithlord23
- skillzundeniable
- skrilla1212
- slc830
- slimeknight
- slippyfist
- Slockhart
- smeeeeee
- SmokMnky
- snappants
- SnrFrijole
- Soma
- SomeCreepyDude
- sonofrich
- SonorousStar
- SorensonX54X
- SPB
- SpeakerDad
- SPEEDBALL
- Spidey2
- Spidey1313
- SpideynSpace
- SplifEOC
- Spooky
- spydermon
- starbucky
- stephens92a
- Stepho
- Stringer
- stustap
- Styjan
- SummerSleep
- supermanfan
- SuperMoore
- supersnac90
- supertrackmonkey
- Sweedy
- SykoZombie
- TaBfan19
- tarrydiggs
- tazz
- tdkelly
- tdog
- techbot
- TechnoViking
- TeddyTreebark
- TeleCarlos
- telltarget2
- Templar
- Tex
- TGibs
- the8thsign
- TheAbominableDan
- TheApeThatEscaped
- thebear
- thebeard
- THEBRODYMAN
- thecannibalisticvagrant
- TheDespicableGent
- thedude
- TheDude007
- TheDudeVonDoom
- theegreatone
- TheEvilCory
- TheFutureMadScientist
- TheGrumpyHatter
- TheGrunger
- THEHOCHE
- theIDENTITY
- thelonelight
- themanagement
- ThePunisherMAX
- TheSecondBatgirl
- thesentinelqte
- theshadetool
- theswordisdrawn
- TheTaken
- thevision
- TheYanni
- thinwhiteduke
- thrillkiller86
- throughthebrush
- tigermojoe
- timothymcgrath
- Tiocore
- Titan72
- tittom
- tjerrod
- tjnewton
- tmvking1
- toadstyle
- tomdpimp
- tomfitz199
- tomhayday
- TomO
- Tomotov2
- Tonyt
- TopGun
- topkat74
- torgelfi
- torippu
- Tork
- Toshimoko29
- tp21361
- trey45
- Trichon
- trobinson79
- Truthseeker
- Tsifox
- turaho
- twistedkaijuu07
- twopossums
- TylerDurden
- UncleBob
- ungaro
- Unoob
- UselessHero
- USPUNX
- vadamowens
- Valcyn
- VegasK
- VelcroKing
- vibrolux
- viceversa
- viewaskew117
- Viewt
- vijay79
- Viktorr
- VisionGX
- VogonPoet30
- WadebeforeSlade
- wader56
- Waka
- wangman31888
- wanner16
- WarrenPeace
- wartsandall
- wheezerhc
- WhiteRedBlack
- whitespyder9
- WildSeven
- willcrimson
- WilliamKScurryJr
- WilliamLund
- wingsfan757
- Wolfdog
- WolkinTexasRanger
- WonderAli
- woodmania
- wrater
- wulfstone
- x2cwaldr
- xebix
- xiseerht
- Xomneon
- XsandOhs
- youngday
- ytsan
- zach
- zachtruitt
- ZackConstantine
- zakcaldwell
- Zalkoran
- zattaric
- zayaz
- zenman
- zlbenson
- ZombiePoo
All users who pulled this comic
Hide users
PENCILS: Oliver Coipel
COVER BY: Oliver Coipel
Size: 40 pages
Price: 3.99
This review contains spoilers, click here to read
I am really starting to agree with Robert Kirkman's Call to Action here. This entire event seems forced so that Marvel can compete with Blackest Night. Seven years in the making my a$$! Brian Michael Bendis did start out as one of my favorite writers, but his writing and payoffs have left me greatly underwhelmed the last 3 years. Two words -- SECRET INVASION. So much potential, huge waste of time and money.
Likewise, this first issue should have been marked as a prologue. There is so much time spent recapping what the audience very well should already know if they are picking up this issue. I found the impetus for the whole Siege situation very contrived and unoriginal. Seriously, for an Asgardian god to be that stupid. But I digress. Even Bendis's trademark dialogue falls short here. Lazy storytelling. As for the final panel? The Captain America situation has been so messed up by Marvel that I found my first thought to be, "shouldn't that be Bucky?" I thought Steve was on a break so that Bucky wouldn't get killed (ala his dream)? What. The. Eff.
As for the art, I truly thought it was mediocre. There was one panel where Victoria Hand comes in to talk to Norman where her face was so badly drawn (Man Jaw, Sloppy Eyes, agrh!), I literally had to do a double take.
I don't know about the rest of you fellas, but I think it's time BMB gets taken off the main books. I have even found his ultimate spiderman to be quite lackluster this past year. He is no longer the architect of the Marvel Universe. Here's hoping that Mickey Mouse will kick Bendis back into shape! Otherwise, it is most definitely time for some fresh blood!
Likewise, this first issue should have been marked as a prologue. There is so much time spent recapping what the audience very well should already know if they are picking up this issue. I found the impetus for the whole Siege situation very contrived and unoriginal. Seriously, for an Asgardian god to be that stupid. But I digress. Even Bendis's trademark dialogue falls short here. Lazy storytelling. As for the final panel? The Captain America situation has been so messed up by Marvel that I found my first thought to be, "shouldn't that be Bucky?" I thought Steve was on a break so that Bucky wouldn't get killed (ala his dream)? What. The. Eff.
As for the art, I truly thought it was mediocre. There was one panel where Victoria Hand comes in to talk to Norman where her face was so badly drawn (Man Jaw, Sloppy Eyes, agrh!), I literally had to do a double take.
I don't know about the rest of you fellas, but I think it's time BMB gets taken off the main books. I have even found his ultimate spiderman to be quite lackluster this past year. He is no longer the architect of the Marvel Universe. Here's hoping that Mickey Mouse will kick Bendis back into shape! Otherwise, it is most definitely time for some fresh blood!
Story: 1 - Poor
Art: 3 - Good
Art: 3 - Good
@RKB: This event really has been planned for seven years, with many of the titles being plotted out just to arrive at this point. It is both impressive, in that there weren’t the same amount of giant flubs that plagued Final Crisis, and disappointing in that, I agree with you, it isn’t very good.
But to say they came up with this just to compete with Blackest Night is fallacy.
@akamuu: Yeah, I get that, but I feel like they have really been rushing through the plot so that they’re events will coincide, y’know? Like I wouldn’t have minded a cleaner transition from Dark Reign to Siege. That would have given them time to fix the Captain America Identity Crisis and clearly shown Norm’s descent into insanity. Also, I’m sure they had the notion to bring back Marvel’s big three after Avengers Disassembled, but did they specifically have the Siege storyline in mind seven years ago? I thought the whole Asgard being on our plane was J.M.S.’s idea…hence my skepticism about "this event" being planned that long ago versus the idea of just undoing what BMS did seven years ago for the sake of sales. Comics are constantly fluid and people come back from the dead all the time. I just feel like they way they are trying to return to the classic hero status quo is a lot like One More Day where there is a lot of magical stuff going on; a sort of quick fix. I was a big fan of Civil War because it was relatively grounded in reality. I believe a more thought out, smart storyline (same goes for OMD) would have benefitted Marvel . This event, after all, is rumored to be one of the reasons JMS left Marvel during his fantastic run on Thor. It just seems like a big gimmick: "Return to Heroic Age"…"NEW Avengers"…."DARK Avengers"….so yeah, sorry for the rant, but that was the thinking behind coming up with Siege to compete with Blackest Night…the idea mightve been there seven years ago, but the choice to implement it now had to be a result of BN; I mean they’re last few issues basically line up perfectly. I don’t mean to offend you, it’s just I don’t have many people to talk comics with! 🙂 so yeah, thanks!
@RKB: I agree with you that the transition feels rushed. I feel like that’s more of bad writing and plotting than a marketing decision, but maybe that’s because we’re different types of cynics. 😉
I’m also in completel agreement that Civil War was a more enjoyable read (for me, anyway) because it was more reality based than "omg, magick!1!1!"
And I wasn’t in any way offended by your review, and certainly not offended by your comment. As someone who works in a comic book store, and deals with a variety of comic readers, you sound like a very reasonable comic fan. If you’re ever in Massachusetts you should stop into one of my stores.