Review by: TheNextChampion

What did the
community think?

Avg Rating: 4.1
Users who pulled this comic:
Users who reviewed this comic:

Size: pages
Price: 2.99

Dear Mr. Remender,

Enough’s, enough Rick Remender. Please get off this title.I know because of the popularity of this book you got your exclusive deal with Marvel. But do us all a favor. Dont write for Punisher anymore, cause you just not good at it. You dont have the voice for Frank Castle, and you made him too cartoony. I understand it’s the regular universe and not the MAX line, but you could do so much more with this story. But the fact is that you give way too many bad one liners for Castle, gives us a very predictable plot, and quite possibly gave me the most ridiculous thing I have ever seen in a comic. What the fuck is Punisher wearing towards the end of this? Is this suppose to be serious or funny? Am I suppose to take this seriously?

Also, tell Jerome Opena that he is also not fit for this title. Sure his pencils look good at first, but when the action gets heavy he doesnt do good panel layouts. I literally got confused a bunch of times on what the hell was suppose to be going on. Again when it’s just talking heads it looks good, but I cant even tell you what was happening in that fire fight with Castle.

So I’m sorry to be a bit harsh with this letter….but like Matt Fraction, your just not good at writing Frank Castle. If your going to have to stay on this title here’s a tip: Call Garth Ennis and Duane Swiercyzski. They know how to write Punisher.

P.S.-Microchip is dead btw, I dont know if you knew that.



Story: 2 - Average
Art: 2 - Average


  1. Yeah, I’m about to drop this myself.  I’ll probably keep MAX around for a while though.

  2. Yep, think I’ll drop this too. I’m not down with the Lynrd Skynrd references and the costume at the end is so lame I don’t even want to know how this one pans out. I’ll stick with the MAX series.

Leave a Comment