FINAL CRISIS #1 (OF 7)

Review by: Tork

What did the
iFanboy
community think?

662
Pulls
Avg Rating: 3.7
 
Users who pulled this comic:


Size: pages
Price: 3.99

This review contains spoilers, click here to read

Story: 4 - Very Good
Art: 4 - Very Good

Comments

  1. >’Grant’s shown in the past that he can tie up confusing or odd plot points well,’

    He HAS?  I’m not saying you’re wrong because I haven’t read all that much Morrison, but in the stuff I am familiar with (52, JLA, X-men, Doom Patrol) I wouldn’t exactly call plotting a strength.

    I hope J’onn isn’t really dead, though.  Grant always did well by him; maybe he comes back as a God or something.

     

  2. I haven’t picked up my books this week, but I have to agree with ohcaroline, Morrison does have a tendancy to not really tie things up particularly well and instead his strenght is in his unique imagination.  Then again I could just be bitter from how he left New X-Men.

  3. Apples and oranges, I’d suspect then.  I actually like his X-Men run and thought he tied things up like Sublime and Kick nicely or like with the whole 4th wall thing in Animal Man.  Of course, I just naturally like weird stuff in comics so that might be it more than anything.

  4. @Tork  I don’t mean I hate his comics (I only hate some of them) but I feel like anybody who goes to Morrison looking for strong plotting is going to be frustrated.  Personally, to enjoy his stuff, I just kind of have to surf on the cool concepts and not think too much about the story logic.

  5. I’m with Tork on this one.

    I think the death wasn’t rushed at all. In fact, I think it was genius. "I’m a baddy. This is what I can do. Join me." He was applying for the biggest badass villian job and the produced on the spot in front of the major players. Grant made a death sequence appear unconventional because it was in fact supposed to be unconventional. This is Grant Morrison folks. It is about pushing the envelope of what typical/normal sequences should occur in a comicbook. Especially one involving a major death. A founding JLA member went lights out pretty fast. This is what it would take to get Luthor and Co. on board. Forget about the "how he got caught" part. It was a great Morrison moment. I loved it.

  6. J’onn’s dead?  I liked that character…  frowny emoticon.

Leave a Comment