Review by: JohnnyDestructo

What did the
community think?

Avg Rating: 3.5
Users who pulled this comic:
Art and cover by JESUS SAIZ

Size: 32 pages
Price: 2.99

Action, suspense, fishnets. What more do you want?

Well, a couple things, actually. Like quality writing, solid art, and strong intelligent female characters. All of which are bases soundly covered in this first issue. Like with many of the positive reviews I’ve given to the DCnU books, I’ve never been a huge fan of The BoP. I’ve only caught a couple issues here and there. I get the main thrust. There are girls, usually led around by the wheelie-poppin’ Oracle, who do…stuff….as a team. So I’m coming at this with (fairly) fresh eyes. And you have to admit, like it or hate it, DCnU certainly has people trying out books they wouldn’t normally bother with, so cheers to them.

While the cover promises a mostly new BoP team of 4 members, we really only get to meet two of them in this issue. Black Canary, whom I’m already aware of, and Starling, of whom I’m less than aware. And so far…I like BOTH of these ladies. I’ve liked Canary ever since I saw her animated in the Justice League cartoons, and she continues to be a steady and self-assured fighter here. Best inner monologue quote: “If we survive this thing, I swear, first order of business…I’m going to recruit another ME.” Cocky? Maybe a little bit, but if you fight off hand-fulls of masked dudes with cloaking tech all by your onesies, you deserve to be a little cocksure. And yes I just realized that I wrote the word cock twice, describing a female character. And I think that this is what I like about BC in this issue. Her part could easily have been written for a man in tights. Swierczynski doesn’t try to sex her up or make her attractive. If you like strong female characters who can kick ass without wearing a thong, you’ll like Black Canary. As for her costume, while it’s definitely more appropriate for a fighter, it lacks the iconic quality of her older outfit. It’s blue and yellow with armor, but I feel like it could be a costume for almost any other female character, and doesn’t specifically scream Black Canary, and for a girl with a screaming power, I’d say that it’s important that her costume reflect that.

And Starling. I dig this one. Nevermind that I have a thing for girls with tat sleeves. Her outfit is slightly more distracting to her male enemies (see also: Boobs), but isn’t anything I don’t see girls wearing on a regular basis (sans sidearms, of course). I like her apparent religious background and her more street level approach to fighting, which makes a nice contrast next to Black Canary. So far, so good with the character interactions and I can’t wait to see what happens when Poison Ivy, Katana and Babs join the series. I hope it keeps up the pace!

The art by Jesus Saiz, while not entirely flashy, is filled with interesting compositions and I loveloveLOVE the backflash transitions. They’re incredibly cinematic in their effectiveness. He uses a particular pose in the present then uses that same exact pose in a completely different setting using a completely different mood to set up the time-rewind. Excellently handled.

This issue is a great jumping-on point …so, you the thing where you jump on!

Story: 4 - Very Good
Art: 4 - Very Good


  1. Totally agree on the flashbacks, they are some of the smoothest and most cinematic I’ve ever seen in a comic! Great review of a great issue!

  2. love me some jesus saiz art, def reading this.

  3. I completely agree with everything you say (as I say in my review), and was especially taken by the little bits of interaction we get between Black Canary and Starling. This is definitely my “Superboy” of the week in that I had little expectations going into a book I knew little about, and came out praying it’s one of the second/third tier books that survives the inevitable decimation of New 52 titles that couldn’t quite make the cut. Here’s hoping!

Leave a Comment