BATMAN: EARTH ONE HC
Review by: pdstacks
What did the
iFanboy
community think?
506
Pulls
Pulls
Avg Rating: 4.5
%7B%22comicdate%22%3A%222012-07-04%22%2C%22comicid%22%3A168308%7D
Users who pulled this comic:
- 23skidoo
- 0157h7
- a.j.howard09
- Achaniel
- adam_zenobi
- adremm
- adrian
- Ainslo
- ajmortys
- AlanRob
- All4ninjas
- Allfather
- amcdole83
- ammcquillen
- anassassinoftheleague
- anrcampbell
- Apotheosize
- arodsalgado
- asigchris
- atma
- avaldez
- B
- BabyFranklin
- bansidhewail
- barryallen
- bassplayer47
- Batwolf
- bazhorne
- BCDX97
- bcoop704
- benfailor
- Bergni01
- bhannaoh
- BigDougJ
- BigE
- bigsime22
- bigyanks
- billysuperhero
- BionicDave
- BioXD
- blast0rama
- bmsovick
- Bnice2me
- BobTaco
- boostergold4
- BowlerdudeMGR
- Brainiac6
- BritishNightwing
- BrNch
- Brotodeau
- Bryce31
- BuckyCap
- butters169
- byoung76
- Cable
- CagedLeo730
- CAM
- camerlane
- CaptainBritain
- CaptDS9E
- Carl_Drogo
- carnivalofsins00
- CaseyJustice
- Cedric
- CelticHart81
- Cerberus
- CGPO
- chad
- CharlesVanMay
- CharlieBlix
- Cheezdog
- chrismcclelland
- ChrisWig
- chrs7637
- ChuckCharming
- Citizensteel
- cjn2525
- clay
- comicBOOKchris
- ComicBookGuy37
- conor
- cornflakes
- Crimson_Torpedo
- Crin
- Crippler
- cromulent
- Cronin
- CronyC
- Croz
- Cslim
- curtisedwardfranklin
- D
- danielnyc
- dark88knight
- DarkKnightJared
- darrenjackson
- DarthYoda
- daveofthedead
- davetv
- davidd
- davidtobin100
- Daximu
- DCdude
- dcrob
- Deadgeek
- Deileon
- Desaad
- DikBallistik
- Doctor_Spidey
- Dogwelder
- dominican_joker
- DonnieD3
- doublea1
- Doughboy
- downisthenewup
- DP1982
- Dream11
- droracle
- drunkentriggaz
- Duderino
- DunDun
- dweebofthedead
- dxhc99
- Eadge
- ed209AF
- edegeyter
- Eitanman
- ElGuaco
- ellerbach
- Ender35k
- endrspkr
- EnyoVD
- erikduane
- essurfer
- est1864
- Excelsior2099
- FamousLastWords
- farisk1
- FarSide0013
- fegcadaver
- fixingtodie
- flaco
- Flash22
- flxlourenco
- FortressLad
- fought13
- Franktiger
- Friedmiester
- Fuchal
- fudd71
- Funcrusher
- FuryofFirestorm
- gallon
- gandalf25
- Gareth
- GarHoch
- Gary4362
- gat0rl1vebeatz
- GeminiTwin
- genelaw9
- getupreggie22
- ghostmann
- gnanniv
- grandemts
- Graphite
- Grayson_Drake
- GreenLanternManny
- gundaRn
- GusSlug
- halik
- harwellpkg
- Haupt
- HBD
- Hellblazer
- henryj2112
- Heroville
- HerrStarr
- heymigs
- hickory
- HipHopHead
- hobley
- Hogue
- HolidayHaley
- homeboy2000
- HossBonaventure
- huntersan182
- iamskeptopotamus
- iiiplace
- inferi22
- IpseVerus
- IroncladMerc
- IronFist
- itsHef
- JackAcid
- jackietam
- JacksonAlexandr
- JamesTheFourth
- JasonTodd
- jasonwest
- JCB
- jeffreyphillips10
- jerriblankstare
- JessD
- JesusChrysler
- JGG
- jguerra
- Jgyorfi
- Jhewlett
- JimGuyJr
- JimShelley
- jjoe23j
- JKExar
- jlobassman
- JLupo
- jmack
- joawmeens
- JoeyDoughnut
- john72tex
- Jolis79
- JonBoy
- Joshrector
- JPtheProdigy
- Jr. Wormwood
- JRoUKno
- jtrigg13
- juand182
- Jvanvic
- JWilliamson
- kamicowzi
- kaonohi
- Kartoffelkopf
- Keith81658
- ketochase
- KevinAB
- kevinscomics
- KickAss
- kineAg62
- KingofGondor
- KISSlover101
- klp044
- knuckleDragger70
- kortum22
- Kory
- koryrosh
- krypto
- ksamara
- kwilli
- Lando
- langdonnicholas
- lantern4life
- Lantern1025
- laridkelly
- Lawless
- Lbmtuc
- LeviHunt15
- LEXPRIME
- lifeinmoments
- lifesend
- lonemagician
- LorryDrivingeek
- lou00
- LRecio
- lucero
- lukehopkins
- macdad34
- MaddGreen
- markavo
- marktomko
- martinNL
- matt
- mattgarcxc9
- matthewAskirble
- MattJ1991
- Maukingbird
- MayorMitch100
- medz
- mephit
- Metamorphic
- mgriffith
- Mi7eM
- michaelwalling
- mickmac59
- mikeandzod21
- MikefromGotham
- mikegraham6
- Mike Sains
- millerc0079
- misterckent
- MisterShaw
- mlilien
- MoniBolis
- monsterduc1000
- Mooz
- Moxieman
- MritalkApple
- mrmccoy81
- MrNoahBdy
- mroberts327
- MrPhases
- muddi900
- mxc
- Myrlyn314
- nacho
- neftones
- newbie2434
- newtype1089
- Nicohdemus
- nightmarewalking
- Nirvanahawk
- NJBaritone
- nl042
- NoahPlaysNintendo
- nodeswitch
- NOK
- notadultyet
- Notahiro
- Noto
- ntn1015
- nwrage
- Obion
- obiwanpomaybo
- odare77
- okc
- oldmanlogan88
- OnASunday
- origamikid
- Ostars103
- Osyris
- Pace
- Painkiller1134
- paorear
- pastard98
- pat44844
- patchcrux1774
- Patient957
- PaulMontgomery
- PaulSharkey
- phess1
- phillyelmo
- phizeta564
- photodrewipa
- pj4life
- Poopmonster
- PostMan87
- pppiquer
- PraxJarvin
- ProjectX2
- ptheiss
- punfun69
- Quasar
- RaBoogie
- Racman
- RadConsv
- RadIrish
- radpuppy71
- RahUniQue
- ralphsix
- RapidEyeMovement
- Ratenef
- RavagerWolf
- ravenfurie
- rayclark
- RedMoses
- Reform
- RerrickDose
- rhaykal
- rhcoop24
- RichMulholland
- RickyStardust
- rivendell3
- rjl
- RKB
- roadcrew1
- robbydzwonar
- Roblaw
- roejamsey
- rogerwhitson
- RoiVampire
- Roldan
- Roly
- RoninA
- ronincubluc
- rosariojav
- Rtousi
- Rustyautoparts
- RyanHoyt
- ryankent160
- ryanorr
- rylosprime
- ryn2o01
- Ryvre
- s1lentslayer
- SamIAm
- Sammy
- Sasquattch
- saxman69
- SBomb232
- scansvc
- Scarface
- ScottE
- Scratch113
- seanpatrickcasey
- SeanStockton
- Sefjoe
- seNoj1
- serge
- ShabaTG
- shanagn7
- shaunbat
- Sica
- Simps
- sirfox89
- Skoon
- Skywalker_303
- Slammaster23
- slickman83
- smitty
- smo5000
- snakeeyesy211
- Soma
- sonnysumo
- spawn
- sphinx69
- spidermanxoxo
- SplifEOC
- StefanFergus
- Stevezie
- stormyinthenorth
- stratychuk_s
- stromtrooper
- strote123
- Suicidalkangarooz
- sullivan85
- sunhero
- superchuck
- SuperGregM
- superkal1978
- SuperMoore
- supersnac90
- sweetesttoaster
- Tamaran
- tazz
- tcglkn
- tdgarza
- Templar
- Tetsu
- TexasZombie99
- th3jok3r
- thebuckshit
- thecannibalisticvagrant
- Thechangingman
- theDANEtrain
- theempireneverended
- TheGunny
- TheSandman
- timvargulish
- tjerrod
- tomc
- tomdpimp
- TomO
- topkat74
- torgelfi
- TrashBoat
- Tribonk
- Trizetacannon
- tschafer
- tyler_durden
- UChess
- UMFskibum
- unclebadtouch
- union20
- unkec
- uvayankee1
- VegasK
- vidiot
- Viewt
- VinyltheFabric
- Vinyl_the_Fabric
- Volrocker74
- wallycee
- wangman31888
- wanner16
- warmachine15
- whitespyder9
- willcrimson
- WinTheWonderboy
- Wondering
- wooble89
- woodpeckerfrommars
- woodyguthrie
- WookieLoveMachine
- wrater
- Wrkn4life
- Wrkngclasshero
- x2cwaldr
- Xenfernox
- Xeno
- xThreshold
- yavinmoon
- zach
- Zedilon
- Zeppo
- ZookZoltn
- zsrtree
All users who pulled this comic
Hide users
Art by Gary Frank
Size: 144 pages
Price: 22.99
This review contains spoilers, click here to read
I approached Batman Earth One, perhaps mistakenly, as a complete graphic novel rather than the first issue of a running title.
As a story written in Earth One independent from New 52 continuity, I expect Johns to create some new, interesting twists, and he does: How did Thomas Wayne and Alfred Pennyworth meet, and what did they do in the desert?; How did Alfred raise Bruce Wayne?; or, if Bruce has not been training with the League of Shadows - I'm assuming he hasn't based on the number of beatings he takes - then where has he been? But Batman Earth One addresses none of these plot points.
Instead, Johns focuses on a Batman who gets pummeled by nondescript rooftop security guards and outwitted by...Mayor Cobblepot. Naturally, an origin story will show a hero's more humble beginnings, but this origin story ends with Batman as ineffectual as he began.
Thankfully, Geoff Johns leaves plenty of pages void of his debasing storytelling so that I can simply sit and enjoy Gary Franks' art, much like the first seven pages. BUT as soon as Batman moans his first word, "OW," and realizes that the best he can do is reach into his fanny-pack and give a homeless woman some cash, I started to wonder, "Who is this loser in the Batman pajamas?"
Story: 2 - Average
Art: 4 - Very Good
Art: 4 - Very Good
Leave a Comment
Login or Register to get involved and leave a comment