Personally, I'll take Vince Colletta's inking over Sinnott and Palmer because he created depth and shadows with his inks that most others can't achieve. Taking nothing away from those two great inkers but Colletta could have copied their styles, not vica-versa. Look at Thor. There was only one Vinnie.
Maybe the hard-core Kirby fans were whipped up into a frenzy about Vinnie because he changed Kirby's pencils but even that was a long time ago. Colletta definitely has a lot of fans, probably why I can't afford his romance books on eBay anymore.
Well finally Marvel did a nice reproduction job on a Thor book.
There is nothing so beautiful in comic-dom as the Jack Kirby and Vince Colletta Thors.
Personally, I'll take Vince Colletta's inking over Sinnott and Palmer because he created depth and shadows with his inks that most others can't achieve. Taking nothing away from those two great inkers but Colletta could have copied their styles, not vica-versa. Look at Thor. There was only one Vinnie.
Maybe the hard-core Kirby fans were whipped up into a frenzy about Vinnie because he changed Kirby's pencils but even that was a long time ago. Colletta definitely has a lot of fans, probably why I can't afford his romance books on eBay anymore.