WOLVERINE #65

Review by: Neb

What did the
iFanboy
community think?

257
Pulls
Avg Rating: 3.8
 
Users who pulled this comic:
Users who reviewed this comic:


Size: pages
Price: 2.99

This review contains spoilers, click here to read

Story: 2 - Average
Art: 4 - Very Good

Comments

  1. Typically good review from Neb.

    I am in agreement about the disappointing nature of this arc – but we all knew it would end this way, didn’t we? Did we really think that Marvel writers and editors would have the guts to kill off a major villain like Mystique, especially in a standard title?

    With regards to killing Wolverine, it seems like the plan would be something like (1) incapacitate Logan to loss of consciousness, (2) cut off his head and limbs, (3) disperse these all over the globe. Don’t know what would happen, but it seems plausible. 

  2. "Also, the ending was very unsatisfying, leaving me to wonder if there was ever a reason for this story arc to begin with.  At the end of the day, we’re right back where we started, which makes me feel like I’ve wasted my time and money."

    I agree with all of that except the last 5 words. I enjoyed the arc alot & felt like I got my moneys worth, with all the cool backstory, action & great artwork.

    This arc was like a kick-ass action movie with tons of explosions & vengeance-seeking-bad-ass tearing through everyone in his path to get to his target … but then he walks away & lets the target live … WTF? 

    Death in comics is rarely permanent — so why couldn’t they end this with Wolverine killing Mystique? The title is "GET MYSTIQUE" … it wasn’t "GET TO MYSTIQUE THEN LET HER GO". He could have at least tried to kill her & she escaped or something. The whole "bleed out, so you suffer more before you die" is a a cop-out. We all know she won’t die.

    Really unsatisfying ending to an awesome storyline. But hey, who am I to question a professional writer who is kicking all kinds of ass in everything he writes these days?

  3.  @coltrane68- I guess I always knew that he wouldn’t kill her, but at the same time I was hoping they’d do something ballsy like that…or maybe end it in a way that didn’t feel cop outish.  And in thinking about your method for killing Wolverine, would this, in turn, grow five different Wolverines? An interesting question indeed. 

    @WadeWilson- I agree with your assessment of those five words.  I guess I didn’t really waste my money because I was really into this arc before this issue.  Call it me being a little over dramatic. 🙂

  4. I had problems with this issue for somewhat different reasons (see my own review), but I don’t think an indestructible character is boring per se.  I just think a writer has to choose the emotional stakes carefully, and in this case they’re not very clear (or I didn’t buy them).  

    @WadeWilson  Don’t you think Logan knows that too?  I would have liked his reasons for walking away to be played out a little more, but I got that he chose not to pull the trigger knowing she’d find a way back.  Maybe because he didn’t think he deserved to be her executioner?  I wish I could read the characterization in this issue a little more clearly, but I think the ending is definitely meant to be ambiguous.  Wolverine isn’t a guy who is necessarily going to mean everything he says.

     

  5. I agree with most of this review. On a few other sites, though, I’m seeing this run being praised as if it were one of the greatest–or THE greatest–Wolverine story of all time, and I hate seeing claims like that. This was a hyped run that lived up to the hype, nothing more or less. I didn’t come in with high expectations so I had my expectations met. The art was great, and the writing and flashback structure was good.

    I have to take points off for its seeming to run on for about an issue longer than it needed to, though. This isn’t even a compression issue. The pages were normally filled with dialogue as well, but I really don’t think this story needed four issues. If it could have been told in only three then I think each issue would have felt more satisfying. And the end of this was a bit underwhelming. I mean, the whole premise is that Wolvie’s tracking down Mystique to get vengence or else some answers–and he doesn’t accomplish either of those objectives. Mystique’s trump card of saying "We’re the same, you and I!" and Wolverine’s final insult to her, of leaving her a gun to shoot herself with–both felt anticlimatic. This would have been better if it didn’t come out of Messiah Complex, because those issues are too serious for Wolverine to just basically ignore them at the end.

    I liked it, though, don’t get me wrong. Nice, exciting story. I hope this isn’t the last time this creative team collaborates on Wolverine.

Leave a Comment