CarolStrick

Name: Carol Strickland

Bio:


Reviews
CarolStrick's Recent Comments
April 10, 2012 11:17 am These seem merely to be four reboots and one fairly preliminary issue which expanded upon what had previously been presented. I'd certainly count neither the JMS nor the current run anywhere near the top 5. (It seems the writer agrees, as he says the JMS run had "terrible execution." How does such then get into a "Top 5" list?) And why is Mod Di credited to O'Neil/Giordano? Sekowsky did the editing, writing and pencilling for the VAST majority of that run. His was the great heart behind it; O'Neil disowns it (and it's true enough that the few O'Neil issues were not the run's shining moments). The comment about crying over Steve Trevor (and calling the run "infamous") (so why is it in a Top 5?) makes me think the writer of this article has never actually read much of that era. Besides, it wasn't truly a reboot. The limited comments about the Perez run reinforces this impression to me for that era as well, as there was MUCH more to that run than merely a string of gods being named in slightly new context. Still, the article brings attention to Wondie. This is a GOOD thing!