wvjdmu

July 29, 2010 10:08 am

I enjoyed Batwomans run on Detective but as that ended I hoped it would get back into the grove and be good. I havent really liked the last issues and this one even though I havent picked it up,  looks like this one is no different .Detective is on my reserve at my comic shop and im hoping it will get better or I might think about canceling it. Its a shame that there are some really great batman books out there and then there are some really bad ones. I started out buying gotham sirens and Streets of gotham, and have stopped collecting them both. Im holding out and hoping that DC will turn this title around.

July 29, 2010 9:57 am This review seems to have a biased view to it, and I have to say I very much disagree with most of the reviewers opinions. Art terrible?? I think thats ridiculous why its not amazing art by any means it worked with the issue and was pretty good, def not terrible. I agree that I probably enjoyed it the least of any issue of this series, but I feel its still a entertaining read that I enjoyed and I really enjoy that savage is in the issue and thomas wayne, or maybe hurt? Also showing Alan Wayne and the building of the wayne mansion was also very interesting. I agree with froggulper that Alans dialogue boxes were very well written as was most of the issue. I Feel the reviewer seemed to already of an idea of how he wanted this issue to be not only with the western aspects but with stewart dropping out on art, also he had problems with Hex not being involved the way He expected him to be. In my opinion horrible review. A review should be a non biased view about the actual issue being reviewed. This was a response from a writer who obviously had his own ideas and opinions about this issue before it was even released, and therefore turned it from a review to a forum for him to share his  many complaints about the issue. I think the issue is well written, not as well as the previous issues, but still is good read. And the art is not cameron stewart, which is what the writer wanted and obvisouly was not open to a replacment, but the art is pretty good overall. If I were to give it a grade I would give it a B - Next time I hope you publish a different writers review or this guy decides to let go of what he thinks an issue should be and go into a read with an open mind. I think he would probably enjoy his comic experience more.