Lotuslaw
Name: Brian McGuire
Bio:
Reviews
Dan Slott deserves high praise for his compelling long-form switch-a-roo. In the build up to a Parker-free Superior Spider-Man, we…
Read full review and commentsI bought my first issue of Invincible some months ago, the one where Vegas was destroyed by Dinosaurus, which I…
Read full review and commentsDon’t care. That fairly well sums up my feeling about these characters when they’re in the New Avengers. Don’t care…
Read full review and commentsAll reviews by Lotuslaw
@ScorpionMasada: Also, I disagree about witty banter and real danger being mutally exclusive. Again, Peter David is a master. For a more recent example, look at Abnett and Lannig over in the Cosmic corner. As for seeing how to use Spider-Man, Busiek's "Untold Tales" is top notch, as is the excellent work done during the "Brand New Day" period. Also, PAD did some good work writing Spidey during that whole Spider Totem garbage, but this was because he really got the character.
You may be right, this may be a style issue. I have liked Bendis's work in other comics. But I just never have found myself caring about his Avengers.
In a way, I never feel like i am reading the character's voice so much as I am reading Bendis's voice thrown into the characters. Don't get me wrong; I have enjoyed issues and moments in his run. But in the end, if Kang came and wiped Luke and Jess from the timestream, I wouldn't care.
In the Harry Potter series, we we told well in advance that important characters would die, but not which ones. Indeed, the technique of "and one will die" is a time-honored plot technique. In comics, toward the end of the Silver Age, there was a graphic novel "The Death of Captain Marvel." Spider-Man 121, the penultmate chapter of the arc with Gwen Stacy's death, has the famous cover with Petey saying "SOMEONE CLOSE TO ME WILL DIE!" and pictures showing various supporting cast. You don't know who will die until you read the issue, but you know someone will.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Night_Gwen_Stacy_Died
Does it really make a difference that you know at the beginnig of the arc instead of the issue? Sure, a shocking death is a storytelling technique as well, but not the *only* one.