ROBIN #181

Review by: akamuu

What did the
iFanboy
community think?

291
Pulls
Avg Rating: 4.0
 
Users who pulled this comic:
Users who reviewed this comic:


Size: pages
Price: 2.99

I give in.  I yield.  I surrender.  I wave the white flag.  I France.  I am bested.

iFanboy really reeeeeeeeeally wants me to read Robin.  So, fine, I delved into the archives and caught up.

I’m really not a fan of the voice-over boxes.  Spoiler’s cursive thoughts, and Tim’s regular printy narration.  I find them incredibly clunky and cumbersome, and, above all, completely unnecessary.  Without them, this would no doubt be a 5 star comic.  The story is great, and the dialogue and artwork are more than sufficient at getting the point across.  I don’t need each character explaining all their motivations in their inner-monologue, when Freddie Williams II does such a good job grafting theit thought process across their faces, and in their postures.  Crediting him as a storyteller as opposed to just artist, is very appropos here.  I kind of want to black out all the square boxes, and read this arc over and over again.

Story: 4 - Very Good
Art: 5 - Excellent

Comments

  1. Is Anarky going to be a big name in the future of DC? Or is he just here to torment Robin for the last couple of issues til it gets canceled?

    I love Anarky, he could totally be a bigger name villain if someone could do him justice…..Grant Morrison if I may say

  2. akamuu akamuu says:

    You may say anything you like in my comments.  Anarchy rules.  As does Anarky.

    I’m not sure how long he’ll be trouncing around the Bat U, but I wouldn’t complain if he sticks around to torment Gotham a little bit longer than just the next issue.

  3. Wicked! Akamuu has time travel powers!

  4. akamuu akamuu says:

    Time travel powers?

  5. Well because you reviewed this before it came out. But you explained over in your Punisher review that you work in a comic book store. I suspected this much when I checked your profile.

  6. stuclach stuclach says:

    "I France."  Well played. 

    I also enjoyed this issue a great deal.  I feel like I have to ask: Is this the best Batbook coming out right now?

  7. Neb Neb says:

    @ stulach~  Batman is the best book coming out right now.  But this one is a close second (and might be tied with Nightwing…maybe).

  8. akamuu akamuu says:

    @ stuclach: I’m enjoying Detective the most this year, and while I’m quasi-excited by the idea of Battle For The Cowl, I’m sad that BoP, Robin & Nightwing all have to go by the wayside.

Leave a Comment