BLACKEST NIGHT #5 (OF 8)
What did the
iFanboy
community think?
Pulls
- 0and18
- 23skidoo
- 70namrepuS
- 0157h7
- 158hoff
- 01011000
- Aalbatr0ss
- aaronjscott
- ABirdseysView
- aboris26
- AbrahamSamable
- AbsoluteMark
- ac507
- acbg
- Achaniel
- acopeland
- ActualButt
- adrian
- adrianhosseini
- adultbraces
- Aeopile
- Agent005
- ajmortys
- Ajs3000
- akamuu
- AL13N4112
- AlanMac
- Alexferrer
- AlexG
- Alfred
- AlphaFlightFan
- AmirCat
- ammcquillen
- AMuldowney
- anachron
- Andrew
- androidmoser
- AngryDad
- Anson17
- anthonyscribner
- APG
- apoptosis81
- Aquaman
- AquaPimp82
- Archr5
- arestocomics
- Aristoi01
- arquilla88
- Art1318
- asholds
- asigchris
- Askanison
- asmith
- astoriajohnstons
- atma
- ato220
- AtomEve
- austinite74
- azrael89
- B
- babaoriley
- baggo
- bakakaba
- Bakhox
- Baltika37
- BandT
- bansidhewail
- BarbarianKing
- Barnabas
- Bassoonjedi
- batmansgirl
- batmanslayer
- BatStewie
- battlecreek
- BC1
- BCDX97
- BCGuy
- bcmiller189
- beatdisciple
- BenBugenig
- benisjamino
- besighyawn
- BetaRayRyan
- betrayl
- bffnut
- bfkiller
- Bibble
- biftec
- BigNobes
- bigsime22
- bigyanks
- bird
- bitingthesun
- BizDaddy
- bizreal1015
- bjohnsonmc
- blackspidey1963
- BladesofJustice
- blaque
- bluedream
- Bluestarblackcar
- bnicholas1
- BobDigi76
- bobstable
- Bobtrombones
- boguspassword123
- BoldCoffee
- BoogieKnight
- Book
- BookGnome
- boostergold4
- braincloud
- Brian
- brianCarbordo
- brianmaru
- BrianPereira
- BrikHed
- BritishNightwing
- broderboy
- Brotodeau
- BruceLuvsClark
- bryanpittard
- Bryce31
- buffalowhig
- bugeyed13
- burn
- bursarman
- busboy
- ButchCassidy
- bzzzash
- c33moose
- cabinboy454
- cactus4million
- CalaveraDeOcho
- CammyKnoxville
- campbell
- canucklehead
- Canyonwalker
- capekweer
- capfsu
- CaptainSweatpants
- captamerica101
- captbastrd
- CaptDS9E
- Cartographer
- CaseyJustice
- cav
- cecena1
- CGHER
- CGPO
- chad
- chadbowen248
- Chadonis
- charlesp1138
- CharlesVanMay
- charliebf5
- CharlieBlix
- chasekanaszka
- chaufschild
- chauncy23
- Cheezdog
- chewie810
- chris
- ChrisB
- chrisbarry5
- chrisequalsgreat
- Chrisflinchbaugh
- ChrisNeseman
- christopheduran
- chrs7637
- Chuckenigma
- chuckles
- Churchill
- citizenmilton
- ckl
- clay
- claynferno
- CleophusWayne
- clintaa
- CloudControl
- cmwnyc
- codepoetmc
- codymander
- Colinski
- comicBOOKchris
- ComicBookGuy37
- ComicGamer
- comixfan
- CongoPepper
- conor
- conor9935
- convoy83
- Cooper
- Corelli
- cornflakes
- Corskione
- CountAbyss
- counterproduct
- CowboyEmpire
- COWoDOOM
- Cranpa
- CrimsonDynamo
- Crin
- Crippler
- cromulent
- CronyC
- Cropcirkill
- crosseyedgreg
- Crucio
- csvaccaro
- ctrosejr
- cutty
- D
- daccampo
- Daflash00
- Dan
- dandoody
- DanFleming
- DanyePD
- danyst
- DarkAzrael716
- DarkKnightDetective
- darkknightwing
- darkmage
- Darksud
- darminion
- darrel
- darrenjackson
- darrinbru
- DarthDuck
- DarthRob
- dave
- daveofthedead
- Davetron3k
- davidd
- DavidMacfarlane
- Dcp
- dcrob
- DDevil1964
- DeadBear
- dedzed
- deezer
- DefConPrime
- defjuan
- Demo916
- DemonBoy
- Demos
- DenverDave
- Desaad
- Devastron
- devinclancy
- Dex
- Dez
- dharmabum
- Diabhol
- djb19538
- DJBeaks
- djd
- djgarciarx
- dneufeld
- docalright
- DocSamson
- Doctor2Geeks
- dodgebullet
- donny
- Doofenschmirtz
- doomwad
- dopehat88
- DorianP
- DorkAvenger
- Doski
- DP1982
- drakedangerz
- drakerivera
- drdeeeznutz
- dredscott33
- drew724
- droll
- droptop80
- droracle
- Drumanespic
- Drummer
- drummerman1126
- dryan
- dsaint
- dukealoops
- DunDun
- dunefish
- dusman7
- dustin
- Eadge
- EAGLEBAUER
- EbonPinion
- ecthelion
- edward
- eganmcconvey
- Ehssan
- Eitanman
- EJ
- Elusion
- ElvisPresto
- emacor72
- EMarq
- emberwistle
- emergencyexit
- emissary
- Ender35k
- enez
- epog
- Eric
- eric501
- EricDee598
- ericwilder
- erikduane
- ERock
- est1864
- esuarez27
- Euhin
- eureka375
- excalipoor
- Excelsior
- exmachina22
- FACE
- fallonk12
- Fanteisimo
- Fantomas
- fearthejake
- felipegarza
- FelixAdler
- Ferrian
- Fett02
- FiascoRodriguez
- Finn007
- flaco
- flakbait
- flapjaxx
- flashfloyd35
- fleaman
- flex20
- Flounder
- flounder56
- FluffNFluff
- ford
- forestjwp
- formerboygenius
- Fourzerotwo
- FraggleUprising
- freakzilla
- Freelancer
- freemansrus
- frijolie
- frodog28
- fudd71
- FunkhornLeghorn
- FuryofFirestorm
- fuso
- Fvckstick
- g0ofgnewt
- Gabe
- Gabrielogan
- gaffergamgee
- gamboa1047
- gandalf25
- Garrett
- gat0rl1vebeatz
- Gaumer
- geekmonkey
- GeminiTwin
- genelaw9
- GENX
- getextinct
- gettsr
- getupreggie22
- GForce
- Ghazzi
- ghettojourno
- gibbs254
- gideon
- GigaShrimp
- Gilgamesh417
- Gimpace
- GIrth
- girvan
- gkelljr
- GKFinns
- GleepGlop
- glunders
- gnanniv
- Goaler31
- gobo
- gollygosh03
- gorf313
- goRimbaud
- gothamcentral79
- Gramercy
- grandemts
- GrayDot
- Grayghost
- greekst
- greendart32
- GreenLanternManny
- gregbmarcus
- Grendel1972
- GrendelRK
- greyseer
- grigs
- grottesco
- gservo
- GungaDin
- Guthriefan
- GutterIsATool
- hakaider
- HankMcCoy
- Harske
- hassler
- Hawkboy
- Hazer75
- HBD
- hbkhumanity
- HecticPlanet
- hellblazer101
- hellboy42
- HermitHomeboy
- Heroville
- HerrStarr
- hexfield
- hickchilli
- hidefjohn
- hoaznod
- HolidayHaley
- Homer
- Hoshigaki
- huddle
- iamskeptopotamus
- Ian
- IanF
- iGotKittyPryde
- iiiplace
- Ilash
- ilovehorsies
- Imjustbettr
- immortal
- Impulse
- incredibledave
- indiophil
- Indycwf
- InfectiousFunk
- insaneshow
- intergy
- introvertedone
- IPunchFace
- irock316
- IronBobby
- IroncladMerc
- iSteve
- itsbecca
- itsHef
- ivithebatmanivi
- Iwelshfanboy
- jabroniunc
- JackAcid
- jakesboox
- james
- JAMESDEAN2020
- jamesschneider
- jamiefs
- JaqueNargg
- Jarrett
- Jasonmatthew
- JayRSy
- JCBlack
- JedeyeSniv
- Jediaxle
- jedidave24
- Jedimasterrob2001
- JediShaft
- Jeffc
- jelontok
- JerB
- jerichobp
- jessefm
- JesTr
- JesusChrysler
- JesusSlanda
- JFernandes
- jfgn
- jforan21
- Jim
- JimBilly4
- JimmyD
- JimmyF1982
- jimmyg
- Jimski
- jing7wei
- Jinnpo
- jisrael
- jjcolin
- jjkish7
- JKExar
- jla728
- jlddlj11
- JLupo
- jmack
- JMF
- JMS74
- jmstump
- joawmeens
- jobob247
- JoeB1ack
- JoeCom
- JoeFX
- John42
- john72tex
- JohnathanKong
- JohnnyStooge
- johnorlandella
- johnthrax
- jonathanzach
- JonBoy
- jonclifton
- JonCrites
- Jonesy
- jonloveless
- jonnjonz
- jono87
- JonSamuelson
- jonwithana
- Joppe
- jordanlyall
- JoseRivera83
- josh
- joshbiz
- Joshrector
- jovianlab
- jpdash
- jpizzy87
- jramsey1
- JRoUKno
- JrSaldivar
- JRScherer
- jsbigman
- jsbx
- jtrem
- jtrigg13
- juand182
- jubal1
- JumpingJupiter
- junoro
- Jurassicalien
- jwimmer
- jwlanglois
- jxc
- k5blazer
- kaonohi
- Katharsis
- Kaylon
- kcekada
- keelatay
- Kenzaburo
- KevBlack
- KevinAB
- kevings
- kevinscomics
- KidJayson
- kidsodapop
- kingpinII
- kingpotato
- KingTorg
- KingYoda
- kingyouth412
- kirkjt
- kndoubleu
- KnightFlight
- Kodaiji
- kortum22
- Koumori
- krad00
- krypto
- kryptogrowl
- KRYPTOTIM
- kubrick1978
- kwisdumb
- kymsoke
- LadyTartan
- lantern4life
- Lantern1025
- LastDays
- Lauren
- Lawless
- lawnbuddha
- Lelandp13
- Leon
- Leprechaun
- levitakis
- Lewis
- lilmikeegee
- lincolnputnam
- LiquidSnake
- liverpoolmunky
- LorryDrivingeek
- lucero
- Lucien21
- LukeB
- Luthor
- macdad34
- magnum240
- MailOrderHero
- malakilii
- Mangaman
- Manos210
- mansuper
- MarcSpector
- marcushill73
- Marie
- markbovenzi
- markfg
- MarkularAdamsmack
- marshak75
- Mart
- martianmonkey
- marvelzombie
- MastaP
- MasterXell
- MastodonBrad
- matt
- mattamatics
- mattfox7669
- mattgarcxc9
- MattGrover
- matthaber
- MattJ1991
- mbren
- mc9457
- mcbaker
- MeanOldPig
- Megnolia
- melwig
- mephit
- mguy77
- micahmyers
- Michael1025
- michaelscott75
- Midness
- midwinter
- mikeandzod21
- MikeDee
- MikeFarley
- mikegraham6
- MikeHaseloff
- MikePositive
- MikeSaxon
- mildmannered
- milez42
- Minion
- misacke
- misterckent
- MisterJ
- mitchster
- Mithel
- mmalone27
- moby66
- modbbt
- mongo
- MoniBolis
- monkeeeboy
- Mookiblaylock
- mosszilla
- MosteXtremeBrian
- MPJB
- MrBeebs37
- mrblondemovie07
- MrDVD14
- MrGlass
- mrlogical
- mrmccoy81
- mrmister
- MrNoahBdy
- MrPhases
- mrtonk
- msryke
- muddi900
- mulletpeep
- Murakami
- musickillsme
- musicologist86
- Mustbedamned
- mxc
- Mxyzptlk
- Mykey
- Myrlyn314
- nacho
- Nate
- nathanhicks
- NawfalQ
- NealAppeal
- Neb
- neerdowell
- neftones
- NeoApocalypse
- NeonVomit
- nerdtastic1227
- neutralfeatures
- newtype1089
- nick0606
- nickfk25
- Nightwing4ever
- NJBaritone
- nmoline
- noasordren
- Nonraw
- Notahiro
- Noto
- Notsoevilsteve
- nroa
- ntn1015
- nyrock
- o1saq
- oaktoad
- obiwanpomaybo
- OccultPanda
- ocdavenger
- odare77
- odino1
- oldmanlogan88
- Omegadark
- OmegaFlight
- omegalife2002
- OnASunday
- Ongakuhenjin
- OniDante
- Orange
- Oranparker
- Orykayd
- Osyris
- outcastjon
- overcommitter
- paorear
- Paradiddle
- Parker
- pathfinda
- patio
- Patman
- Patman2
- PatShatner
- PaulAllor
- paulieP
- PaulMontgomery
- petefic
- peterporker
- Petro09
- petropeterson
- petrorabbit
- PhantomPhrenemy
- phillyelmo
- phizeta564
- Pico
- PiePod
- Pilled
- piscespaul
- plikt
- pmc6284
- Poddington
- Pompster
- PostMan87
- PozrDu
- PraxJarvin
- Preacher
- Prime
- ProjectX2
- puffnstuph
- Pumatastic
- punisher36
- punisher1135
- pup
- PV
- PymSlap
- queenrikki
- Quentin
- Quinn
- RABinRVA
- RadConsv
- RahUniQue
- ramonschenk
- Ramulux
- RandoCalrissian
- ratekin
- Ratenef
- rayclark
- RazorEdge757
- redcracker
- redhood22
- redlibertyx
- redline925
- redsoxofkc
- reg5000
- Reverend13
- reversematt
- RevJred
- RevolutionarySounds
- rgrudinski
- rhcoop24
- rian
- richardelgie
- rift1128
- RipperSix
- rivendell3
- rjl
- rjw3
- RKB
- RLPrime
- RMC
- roadcrew1
- robbiethegeek
- robertcorbet
- Roblaw
- robsavino
- rochvail
- RocketRacoon
- rockgod27
- roejamsey
- Rofo
- RogueWarrior76
- RoiVampire
- RolandofGilead
- ron
- Rooney
- rrrafa
- rsmorley
- Rtousi
- rubra
- rudeboy134
- runawayjim
- Ruo21
- Rustyautoparts
- rwpos
- RyanHoyt
- ryn2o01
- ryry
- ryu156
- s73v3r
- SalPane
- SamIAm
- Sammy
- sandman300
- Sasquattch
- saturnmda
- Sauceda
- Saul
- saweez
- SBomb232
- scallionsncreme
- Scarecreaux
- scim
- SCOOTMAN
- ScorpionMasada
- ScottR33
- Scotty
- SeanStockton
- Selfstyler
- selftitled
- seNoj1
- Serdan66
- sethkushner
- Shamrock
- shaunbat
- ShonenRafa77
- SilentRob
- SilverAgeTom
- Simmons
- Simon
- sinclairtyler
- siraim
- siratomofbones
- SirCut
- Sirhc6934
- SirSullymore
- skeets
- skillzundeniable
- Skyhawke
- slimeknight
- slippyfist
- Slockhart
- Smasher
- smeeeeee
- smoggy
- SmokMnky
- snackbidi
- SnrFrijole
- Soma
- SomeCreepyDude
- somethingblue13
- sonnysumo
- sonofrich
- SonorousStar
- southbymidwest
- SPB
- SpeakerDad
- speaknspell
- SPEEDBALL
- Spidey2
- SpideynSpace
- Spigs
- Splashpage
- spndx
- spongebat
- Spooky
- Spoons
- Stepho
- steveh
- stoneboy
- StormShadowBeat
- stormy504
- stromtrooper
- stuclach
- stustap
- SummerSleep
- superchuck
- SuperGregM
- Superhands
- supermanfan
- SuperMoore
- supersnac90
- supertrackmonkey
- SykoZombie
- sythspawn
- t1deman
- Tamaran
- tangeroo
- taozen
- tarrydiggs
- tazz
- tdkelly
- techbot
- TechnoViking
- TehDave
- telegraph
- Templar
- terminaljunkie3
- Tex
- TGibs
- the8thsign
- TheAbominableDan
- TheApeThatEscaped
- thebear
- THEBRODYMAN
- thecannibalisticvagrant
- TheConfessor
- TheDespicableGent
- thedude
- TheDude007
- TheDudeVonDoom
- theegreatone
- thefig24
- thefreakytiki
- TheFutureMadScientist
- TheGrumpyHatter
- TheGrunger
- TheGunny
- THEHOCHE
- theIDENTITY
- TheKZA
- thelonelight
- themanagement
- TheNextChampion
- ThePunisherMAX
- thescimitar
- TheSecondBatgirl
- theshadetool
- TheTaken
- TheYanni
- thinwhiteduke
- thisisegan
- ThomasKaters
- thorin
- throughthebrush
- tigermojoe
- TimmyWood
- timothymcgrath
- Tiocore
- Titan72
- tjerrod
- tjnewton
- toadstyle
- Todd
- toddkelley
- tomdpimp
- TomO
- Tomotov2
- Tonyt
- TopGun
- topkat74
- torgelfi
- torippu
- Tork
- Toshimoko29
- Trichon
- trobinson79
- trugamer510
- Truthseeker
- tschafer
- Tsifox
- tuborg99
- turaho
- twistedkaijuu07
- twooldridge
- twopossums
- TylerDurden
- uberlush
- ultimatehoratio
- UncleBob
- ungaro
- unkec
- Unoob
- usagi
- UselessHero
- uuuhyeah
- uvayankee1
- vadamowens
- Valcyn
- VegasK
- VelcroKing
- vHeltervSkelter
- vibrolux
- VicDeZen
- VichusSmith
- viewaskew117
- Viewt
- vijay79
- viktorfrieze
- VisionGX
- Vocaltic
- VogonPoet30
- vtlogypj
- WadebeforeSlade
- WadeWilson
- WalkingCalamity
- wangman31888
- wanner16
- wartsandall
- watchthesparks
- weaponx
- Webhead
- weddleb
- Weddlefufu
- WeezyWill
- WeRideToFight
- wheezerhc
- WhiteLantern
- WhiteRedBlack
- whitespyder9
- whyda
- WildSeven
- Wilko77
- willcrimson
- willelmagnifico
- WilliamKScurryJr
- wilson6923
- wingsfan757
- WinTheWonderboy
- WJWitherspoon
- wolf
- Wolfdog
- WolkinTexasRanger
- WonderAli
- woodmania
- wrater
- Wrkn4life
- wulfstone
- x2cwaldr
- xebix
- xiseerht
- xmanslade
- Xomneon
- XsandOhs
- YannickV
- yetihands
- youngday
- ytsan
- zach
- zachtruitt
- zack
- ZackConstantine
- zak7khan
- Zak71296
- Zalkoran
- zayaz
- zenman
- Zeppo
- zerodni
- znatit
- ZombiePoo
- zombox
- ZookZoltn
Size: pages
Price: 3.99
This review contains spoilers, click here to read
Pro
-Man, if there is a guy that is almost a shoe in for 'Artist of the Year' it would have to be Ivan Reis. What he's done for five straight issues have been amazing. There are some two page spreads in this issue that would put other artists to shame. In fact there was a lot of two page spreads in this, so Reis definitely had his work cut out for him for this issue. So much detail in every single panel though too. I've mentioned before on how his take on the Flash is just amazing and better then Ethan Van Sciver. Well now that we see all of the Flash family for this issue, I have no doubt that Reis should do the Flash ongoing. No offense to Manapul of course...
-So many moments in this it's amazing! Oh my god! Bruce Wayne is back! The rest of the DCU is ready to kick ass! Oh no's! The DCU heroes have now turned into Black Lanterns! Oh my god! Barry and Hal are next!! Again all of these moments are exciting and definitely seem to come from the mind of Geoff Johns. Speaking of 'Holy shit moments'....
Con
-Practically no story progression in this. In fact if we had to count it, all of the story comes from Green Lantern #48 this week. There is nothing in hear that says 'we moved the story along'. All this was for this issue was 'holy shit moments' and nothing else. That's just not enough for me guys, I'm sorry. Sure these moments are great and they are shocking, but that's not enough for an issue for me. I want story progression, especially if we are now at the halfway point of this thing. If I have to see story progression in the tie-ins and other GL books, than that is a huge problem.
-Other little things annoyed me, like the stuff with the Lanterns in the beginning. That stuff with Larfleeze felt so damn forced to be funny and it just wasn't. Then you have Carol Danvers.....basically being useless more then anything else. I should've mentioned that in the Green Lantern #48 review but seriously. What purpose does Carol serve in this? Sayd and Ganthet has had more lines then her!
-Other bad jokes in this, specifically with Hal. His one liners were clunkers and it felt like I was reading the script of a bad action movie. Even the banter between Hal and Barry wasn't enough for me.
-Finally, way to blow an interesting angle with the new Dove. Apparently she has the power to destroy the Black Lanterns and the Teen Titans mini (at least I heard) showed how important she was as a character. What do we get for this issue? Just a throw away line and panel showing her 'powers'. Disappointing.
You know what this feels an awful like? Secret Invasion #4. Both feel practically the same when it comes to the events. They both started out promising, had great storylines (in other comics) to pump us for the event, and now.....Both are looking really disappointing. Just like Secret Invasion (and practically Geoff Johns) it has disappointed me because it's nothing but 'cool comic book moments' and barely any real story to it. Okay so the dead are coming back and Nekron is pissed.....But is that all we're gonna get for the next three issues? Sure it has amazing artwork by Reis, but so did Secret Invasion with Yu. It's amazing just how close this is to that disappointing and frustrating Marvel event. The only hope I have is that this was just a set back and the next issue will deliever something more. If Geoff Johns doesn't do that, I'm not going to stay around to get burned by an event once again.
Art: 5 - Excellent
I… actually agree with this review. 😉
Just curious, but how are the ‘holy shit moments’ not moving the story along? We find have a little resolution on Bruce Wayne’s skull, we have the only plan to defeat the Black Lanterns proven unuseful, we have Nekron addressing his problem with resurrected heroes. How do these moments not move the story along?
I’d say what he means is that we had a Nekron reveal last time, and this time it’s just a bunch of people fighting him. The Bruce Wayne thing was cool, but all it did was put rings on more people’s fingers. It wasn’t really much of a plot device, all told.
For me, I can agree that the story is moving along. I just think the story being told is really kind of average. A villain gets an upgrade and comes after heroes and a bunch of colored lanterns come together, and the villain grabs more heroes and makes them evil… I dunno, there are a bunch of plot points, but I don’t feel there’s a lot of depth here. Just IMHO, of course.
This was an outstanding issue. I would rank it just behind issue #1. This completely out shines an average Secret Invasion story in many ways.
@Rusty: Basically what @daccampo said.
Sure some of these moments move the story SOMEWHAT, but they don’t add to the overall narrative. Bruce coming back for a spilt second, or the BL Guardian dying are just tiny, insignifigent portions of the story.
Daccampo is right, the story being told right now is very average. It’s only considered ‘amazing’ because Geoff Johns is continually throwing in ‘holy shit’ moments to distract the readers.
I respectfully disagree, but hey, ces’t la vie.
@tnc: I agree on all points. Until the Bruce Wayne reveal I was completely disappointed in this issue. And while the Wayne reveal, and the final reveal were interesting, they didn’t, to me, justify having to slog through the rest of the book.
Sometimes, you have to have Explosions, Gun fights, and Car Chases. Especially in an action story. They serve no other purpose than to take our breath away, and make us say "Woah! Cool!". Especially in an action based medium, like traditional super hero comics. And some characters only purpose for that part of the story, is to stand there shooting their weapons and/or getting their butts kicked. Sometimes those moments are the characterization.
Come down off the mountain and revel in it with us. We welcome you. It’s fun. And sometimes…. it’s the whole point.