BATMAN #682

Review by: akamuu

What did the
iFanboy
community think?

658
Pulls
Avg Rating: 3.9
 
Users who pulled this comic:


Size: pages
Price: 2.99

This comic really makes me anxious to see Neil Gaiman’s upcoming arc.

It’s nothing against Mr. Morrison.  I love most of what he’s written, The Invisibles, The Filth, Animal Man, and The Authority were brilliant, and his X-Men run was epically good right until he wrote the giant middle finger to Marvel ending.  I even didn’t hate his JLA run, which is more praise than it sounds, as I’ve never been intrigued by the JLA or JSA titles.  All that said, I was slightly dissapointed in RIP, and completely bored with this follow up issue.

I’m not exactly sure where Morrison lost me on this Batman run.  I liked the creation of Damian, the interaction with the Al Ghuls, and the idea of the Black Glove.  I understand that oen of the main reasons I didn’t get all there was to understand in Batman RIP is because, in the last issue he tied in things from the Robin, Nightwing, The Outsiders, and Detective; all of which I read in trade, but not in issues.  I also stopped reading the main Final Crisis story, as it seems too schizophrenic (while all of the tie-ins I’ve read have been focused and afuckenstoundingly good).  So I have to reserve judgement on RIP until I read everything its related to.  The same isn’t true for Last Rites.

This issue seems epiloguish, while, at the same time, is a super compact retelling of The Batman mythos.  A story that’s been hashed, rehashed, hash browned, hash piped, hashished, and then hashacalifragelisticexpialidoshished again.  The occasional retelling is neccesary to draw in new readers, I understand that.  But a compact retelling of a mythos should either include some new reveal to intrigue long time readers, or else be simple enough for new readers to understand.  This issue was just a clusterfuck of memories.  Pretty to look at, but empty at the center. 

Maybe the next issue will wrap everything up into some sensical order, but I doubt it.  This is Morrison, a great writer who doesn’t always wrap his stories up into neat little packages.  In fact, sometimes you unwrap his shiny wrapped presents and discover you’ve been given a ripped cardboard box full of someone else’s broken teeth.  And not even a complete set of teeth.  And what teeth there are have been chipped.  But, uh, I guess the box was pretty.  That’s, at least…something?

Story: 1 - Poor
Art: 4 - Very Good

Comments

  1. "hashacalifragelisticexpialidoshished" — LOL Nice!

    "This issue was just a clusterfuck of memories.  Pretty to look at, but empty at the center.  "

    I agree. Retelling the mythos for new readers is obviously a good thing, but when it’s told in a way that only Starman in JSA could follow, then it’s kinda pointless. Imagine someone new to Batman comics, who is interested in his background trying to make sense of this issue … 

     

  2. At some point, I want to sit down and read all the RIP titles back to back, and this one.  Maybe even go all the way back to the start of Batman & Son, and see if this issue makes any more sense.

Leave a Comment