Pick of the Week Podcast

02.07.2010 – Episode #220 – Siege #2

Show Notes

Running Time: 00:59:06

February 7, 2010 – The gang's all here as Conor Kilpatrick, Ron Richards and Josh Flanagan gather together after a long day of work to babble about the week's comics. And not just some of the comics. In a special one-time only event, the iFanboys break format and talk about ALL of the comics that they read from the past week. Who's idea was this? They don't know but they'd like to find him or her and kick their ass.

Comics:
00:02:15 – Ron's Pick of the Week: Siege #2
00:12:06 - Wolverine: Weapon X #10
00:16:18 - Scalped #34
00:18:40 - Sweet Tooth #6
00:21:00 - Red Robin #9
00:23:01 - Buffy the Vampire Slayer #32
00:25:19 - Demo Vol. 2 #1
00:27:57 - Justice Society of America Annual #2
00:29:15 - Jonah Hex #52
00:30:11 - Criminal: The Sinners #4
00:31:26 - Invincible Iron Man #23
00:36:37 - Nova #34
00:37:35 - Blackest Night: The Question #37
00:38:30 - Blackest Night: Wonder Woman #3
00:40:18 - Batman Confidential #41
00:40:35 - Cable #23
00:41:28 - Marvel Heartbreakers
00:42:29 - Savage Dragon #157
00:42:55 – Doom Patrol #7
00:43:53 - G.I. Joe Origins #12
00:45:08 – Superman: World of New Krypton #12

User Reviews
00:46:23 - glwarm76 did not enjoy Siege: Embedded #2.
00:48:51 - ActualButt was surprised to find that he did enjoy Ultimate Comics X #1.

GIVEAWAY
The four lucky iFanboy Members who will be getting some awesome Planet Hulk movie prizes are:

GRAND PRIZE WINNERS — Planet Hulk poster signed by Alex Ross!

Timothy Boysen
Dale Philbrick

RUNNER-UP WINNER — Planet Hulk on Blu-Ray!

Mathew Scaba

RUNNER-UP WINNER — Planet Hulk on DVD!

Chris Schmidt

February is another giveaway month and only iFanboy Members are elligible to win iFanboy Giveaways! If you're not a member, sign up to win! 

Etc.:
Do like Rick Remender says and buy a limited edition FEAR AGENT Shirt!

Go subscribe to iFanboy: Don't Miss to hear a preview of a book coming out this week.

Sponsors:
This episode of iFanboy is brought to you by:

C2E2, the Chicago Comic and Entertainment Expo comes to Chicago this April 16th through the 18th.

Special guests for this year's show include Alex Ross, Jeff Smith, Geoff Johns, Mike Mignola, Ethan Van Sciver and hundreds more of your favorite creators. Tickets are only $25 for a one day pass, and $50 for the entire weekend!  For a full list of guests, events and to purchase tickets, visit C2E2.com

C2E2 & iFanboy are giving you a chance to win tickets and exclusive C2E2 merchandise before the big weekend. We'll be giving away 1 amazing VIP package,  3 weekend passes, 5 exclusive C2E2 posters signed by creator & Guest of Honor Alex Ross and 15 limited edition C2E2 t-shirts and the grand prize is lunch with an editor from Marvel!

Just visit www.c2e2.com/ifanboy and enter your name and e-mail. We'll be drawing winners from all the entries on March 19th.

Instock Trades – Save up to 37% on trade paperbacks, hardcovers and collected editions.  With over 9,000 titles in stock and available to order, orders ship within 48 hours.  Go to www.instocktrades.com and make your order today

And mark your calendars for the Summit City Comic Con on May 22 in Fort Wayne Indiana – www.summitcitycomiccon.com

Audible.com – Home of over 60,000 audio books, Audible has something for you – get a FREE audiobook download and 14 day trial at audiblepodcast.com/ifanboy

Music:
A Praise Chorus
Jimmy Eat World

Download

http://media.libsyn.com/media/ifanboy/iF...
(Right-click and choose "Save As..." and save locally)

Subscribe

Get Involved

Doing the podcast is fun and all, but let's be honest, listening to the 3 of us talk to each other can get repetitive, so we look to you, the iFanboy listeners to participate in the podcast! "How can I get in on the fun?" you may ask yourself, well here's how:

  • E-Mail us at contact@ifanboy.com with any questions, comments or anything that may be on your mind.
  • Call us at 1-888-FANBOYS (326-2697) and leave a voicemail

Please don't forget to leave your name and where you're writing/calling from and each week, we'll pick the best e-mails and voicemails to include on the podcast!

Comments

  1. Chris Rohling Anson17 says:

    The Hmong gang is from the Twin Cities. There are some hardcore Hmong gangs in the area. When they showed up in Scalped I kinda freaked out a bit.

  2. MattB MattB says:

    Great show as per usual guys shocked to hear u like Ultimate X I refuse to buy any book with loebs name on it and contend that the only diffrence between him and chuck austin is that he was smart enough to A. rip off the godfather and B. team up with tim sale also i have my fingers crossed that the sentry dies a horrible violent death and is then blinked out of the universe.

  3. OwlyFan says:

    It’s going to be on a long week at work, but this should help it get off to a good start.  Thanks!

  4. Ilash Ilash says:

    Great show guys. All I know is that I’m glad that I’m not the only one who was underwhelmed by Demo Volume 1 and I still agree with Josh in picking Scalped over Blackest Night. 

    And, man, that was a whole lotta books! 

  5. KickAss KickAss says:

    Who ripped off the Godfather? In what book?

  6. MattB MattB says:

    @KickAss Jeph Loeb did The Long Halloween and to a lesser extent dark victory

  7. You guys didn’t like Bad Night? That arc was killer (and I know it’s Bru’s favorite).

  8. NathanNicdao NathanNicdao says:

    Wow. Covered all my books plus a ton more. It even lacks description. And all that in a shorter time!

  9. edward says:

    You know, it’s funny. If the Sentry’s thing is flying away and whinging; the ifanboys’ thing is doing a podcast and whinging about the Sentry… every week

  10. flapjaxx flapjaxx says:

    Whew look at all those books listed in the rundown. This is going to be good–I would never buy or read Cable (tried the first ish, tho), but I like the prospect of hearing Ron talk about Cable #23 while Josh and Conor are forced to listen. Cheers as always, guys.

  11. Heroville Heroville says:

    Conor there was a bit of a Aquaman/Wonder Woman ship going on in Morrison’s JLA; it wasn’t overt but it was there.

  12. Conor Kilpatrick conor (@cskilpatrick) says:

    @Heroville: Yes, I know. I did a Mini that dealt with it.

  13. Conor Kilpatrick conor (@cskilpatrick) says:

    @Heroville: We weren’t talking about a Aquaman/Wonder Woman relationship on the show this week, though. We were talking about Batman/Wonder Woman.

  14. genelaw9 genelaw9 says:

    This podcast was THE best way to ignore the Super Bowl halftime splatter. 

  15. UncleBob UncleBob says:

    It seems like Cap coming back and his reaction to the status quo is leading up to a showdown w Osborn.

    It is cool, but I don’t know….

    I feel that only one person should be taking his ass down (Spidey).

     

    Thoughts anyone?

  16. edward says:

    Joe Kelly did a JLA story after Morrison and Waid where Wonder Woman and Batman hooked up in a future vision thingy. Bruce is a-sexual he’ll never hook up

  17. Slockhart Slockhart says:

    "I come back here and WHAT THE FUCK!" – Currently the quote of the year.

    First episode where every book I read is covered… gotta say, that’s a nice feeling.

  18. DarthDuck DarthDuck says:

    I’m with you UncleBob – It should be Spidey.  But will it?  No idea, Cap and Iron Man and even Thor all have legit reasons to will be/want to be the one.

    I want it to be Spidey, but if its a situation where he’s beaten and they let him make a ‘statement’ punch or something like that, then I’d be upset.

  19. Jim Mroczkowski Jimski (@jimski) says:

    I won’t say Spider-Man has been disengaged during Dark Reign, but he has certainly handled Norman’s rise to power better than I would in his place. I suppose he has gotten used to the world dumping on him. Still, they’ve gotten me to the point now where I forget Norm was ever a Spider-Man villain. Can you imagine forgetting the Red Skull was a Cap villain?

  20. edward says:

    yes, but think it. About The Kingpin started off as a Spiderman villian, who do you think of when The Kingpin’s mentioned now?

     Characters move on. If they don’t, you get the sames story over and over which sucks

  21. COWoDOOM COWoDOOM says:

    Great show, Glad you mentioned Volstag ont the goblin glider. I giggled with glee when I saw that pannel. My roommate thought I was weird, until I showed him the pannel.

  22. BornIn1142 BornIn1142 says:

    Objection! Wolverine cares for X-23 quite a bit.

  23. BC1 BC1 says:

    On the blood with Ares: I think it’s incredibly appropriate. When you look at books like th Iliad and the Aeneid, people die in graphic, violent and horrific ways. For Ares, a product ultimately of this literature, to go out as he did was exactly as it should be. I’m glad Coipiel didn’t pull punches.

  24. jackietam jackietam says:

    Awesome show, guys. I have to admit I kind of prefer the previous format since it give you guys more time to discuss each new book, instead of spending time worrying about getting every single book in your 1 hour podcast.

  25. jackietam jackietam says:

    One more thing: how comes Jessica Jones was nowhere to be found in the double spread in the Siege 2? Unless I’m mistaken, she is still an avenger.

  26. WonderManFan WonderManFan says:

    HOORAY! Greatest podcast ever! Thank you for covering all the books. This kind of podcast is exactly what I’m looking for in a weekly podcast. Thank you for doing what I requested so long ago. I know you guys sounded like you didn’t enjoy it as much as the usual ten weekly books, but I’m very happy you gave it a shot. I thought it was great. Thank you for listening to your fans.

  27. ohcaroline ohcaroline says:

    Jessica Jones has never been an Avenger.  She busted out the costume, I think, for the Annual where they rescued Clint, but nothing was said about her joining the team. 

  28. Mangaman Mangaman says:

    @MattB: same here buddy, same here. I really don’t know why they enjoyed it (haven’t heard the podcast yet) but I’m curious to hear what they have to say about it that could possibly vindicate Loeb.

  29. Mangaman Mangaman says:

    heh, showcase a review NOT liking Embedded (the one I loved) and a review of that god awful Ultimate X #1. You guys must be bizarro ifanboy.

  30. Conor Kilpatrick conor (@cskilpatrick) says:

    @Mangaman: Well, since we are actually iFanboy, it makes more sense that you are Bizarro iFanboy.

  31. Conor Kilpatrick conor (@cskilpatrick) says:

    @Mangaman: Not that any of that makes sense in relation to what we actually talked about because we all really liked SIEGE EMBEDDED #2.

  32. Maybe that Loeb laid off the lame fight scenes, shitload of special guests, hundred (hyperbole) double-page spreads/splash pages and told a relatively quiet story with some characterization and development. 

  33. AmirCat AmirCat says:

    @Heroville – That explains it! The Wonderwoman vision!

     

    Conor’s Aquaman Mini:

    http://www.ifanboy.com/podcasts/video/iFanboy_Mini_-_Episode__18_-_What_s_Wrong_With_Aquaman_

  34. Great episode, although I am suprised to hear ron say this issue of Weapon X is the best Wolverine issue….Ever!

    Really? I mean I am not a Wolverine fanboy but I could of classic stories probably better then this issue. Then again it was good, not going to argue that.

  35. flapjaxx flapjaxx says:

    Yeah, c’mon, Ron. "Best Wolverine Story Ever"? The art was great, but the story features Logan playing CHESS and acting like he’s doing an impression of some typical 30-something guy from an NBC sitcom. Love doesn’t have to make sense, but there was little build-up to Logan all of a sudden changing "who he is" to be with this random woman. Are you sure you just didn’t like it because there was a Smiths/Morrissey reference? Overall, it was okay, though, don’t think I hated it.

    Great ep overall, guys. You’re on the verge of convincing me to give Siege a try even though I usually don’t like Bendis Avengers stuff. You may not realize how big of an accomplishment that is, at this point.

  36. Mart Mart says:

    I really enjoyed this episode, it was packed and pacey. Nice one, I hope you do it again sometime.

    Conor, surely an anthology is one book with a number of stories in it, maybe by the same creators, maybe by different ones. Sounds like Demo is a series of one-shots such as, say, DC’s old First Issue Special. I’m not sure you could consider a series an anthology, but collect the things in one volume and no argument. 

    Olivier Coipel does indeed just get better – I wish DC would collect his Legion of Super-Heroes work with Abnett and Lanning – cracking stuff!

  37. Conor Kilpatrick conor (@cskilpatrick) says:

    @Mart: We’re never doing this format again.

    DEMO is definitely an anthology.

  38. UncleBob UncleBob says:

    @Conor:  that’s too bad.  It still was 1 hour.

  39. Mart Mart says:

    @Conor But . . . but . . . you were MAGNIFICENT!

  40. Urthona Urthona says:

    Yea, Conor, know you don’t want to listen, and you guys kept talking about how bad the format was, etc, etc, but I really enjoyed the show.  But then, I pretty much enjoy all your shows…thanks!  Believe it or not, even hearing Ron say "Got nothing to say about Savage Dragon, I love it, it’s great, move on…" was informative and interesting.

     

  41. Urthona Urthona says:

    And, oh yea, DEMO is not an anthology, no matter how many times you say it. :-)

  42. Conor Kilpatrick conor (@cskilpatrick) says:

    You can believe what you like.

  43. RobAbsten RobAbsten says:

    1) Great show. 

     

    2) HOG Butcher for the World,

         Tool Maker, Stacker of Wheat,
         Player with Railroads and the Nation’s Freight Handler;
         Stormy, husky, brawling,

         City of the Big Shoulders: 

     

    Carl Sandburg: "Chicago" (Emphasis added)

Leave a Comment